Connect with us

Peripherals

Composite testing of microSD memory cards with capacity of 64 GB

Advertisement
Laptop Power Inverters, Free Shipping!

If you want to choose the best memory card for camera or smartphone, but you are not sure, then you have come to the right place. In this article, we talk about differ from one another in-market memory card, and give practical response to the question, what specific memory card may be better in certain scenarios.

In 2018 the memory card is ubiquitous. They are used in many types of consumer electronics ranging from phones and cameras to laptops, drones, and video recorders. Quality work all these gadgets directly depends on how relevant to them is a hand-picked card. And it’s not just in capacity: capacity of memory cards, as their price can vary significantly, and different gadgets impose completely different requirements to the speed of the used media. If the memory card is selected incorrectly, it may directly affect the operation of the gadget — to the point that he even refuses to perform its functions. Therefore, the study of the practical characteristics of memory cards under load of different types is a very important study, which allows you to find the most suitable for each variant, while not overpaying for useless features.

#Is a little about the history and standardization of the SD card

Standard memory cards Secure Digital (SD or briefly) acquired widespread in the early 2000s, after in 1999 the three companies – SanDisk, Panasonic and Toshiba – have decided to unite and develop a unified specification compact removable media based on flash memory. Now, after almost two decades from that moment, you can already confidently say that the goal was achieved. The initiative caught on, and the SD card have actually become a unified industry standard, despite the fact that produce these memory cards dozens of companies. An excellent illustration of the success of standard SD cards may be the fact that now in the development and implementation of this standard is somehow involved more than eight hundred different companies. This is good news.

The bad news is that, despite the existence of a single standardization body, special organization of the SD Association, without zoo of different types of memory cards the deal is still not done. On the market cards are different form factors, capacities and performance classes. Moreover, although in General the devices made in accordance with a common standard and for the most part compatible with each other, they are not interchangeable. Part of on the market cards are better suited to download apps and work in Android smartphones because they have the best performance during operations random read, others are better at sequential operations, which is critical for recording high resolution videos, photos, and more.

The SD Association has done a lot of engineering work to develop a technical standard compact media, but outreach and marketing activities of this Association raises many questions. What, for example, is the fact that each new version of the SD specification were introduced into circulation a new classification of high-speed parameters and added to the existing new variants of marking. In addition, the names of the types of memory cards were added various modifiers, and to date the situation has come to a point where numerous logos on the package flash-cards, even an expert will not be able to define what it is to be expected in practical use. But do not fear: in this article we present a simple and detailed explanation of classification cards, and in addition, we compare the actual performance of the most relevant cards microSD 64 GB.

#Form factors SD card

The simple and clear distinction between different SD cards is their physical size. Despite the fact that at a logical level, no differences between the different form factors, there is three different size memory cards: standard, mini and micro.

It is obvious that the cards of different size are used in different types of devices, and more compact cards are usually used in a more portable gadgets. In this case, since SD, MiniSD and MicroSD are made in accordance with a common standard, they can be interchanged using simple adapters. Thus, the most compact MicroSD cards often come with the adapter that allows their use in full size SD slots, and backward compatibility is not affected. The use of adapter has no effect neither on speed, nor on anything else. So microSD cards are the most versatile option and can be installed in devices with a microSD slot and a normal SD slot.

Card microSD with adapter for standard slots

As for form factor MiniSD, he in modern devices it is almost never used. Moreover, it is not exaggeration to say that today he is dead.

#Capacity and types standard

The capacity of the memory card is, perhaps, another obvious feature. Although SD cards may have a size from 1 MB to 2 TB (and in the future – and even more) confused here is extremely difficult, especially as on any memory card, its capacity in gigabytes is specified in such a large font that not find or correctly read this value impossible.

However, the SD Association has worked hard to ensure that ordinary people got some headache even here. The fact is that depending on the capacity of the SD card refers to the different types are: SDSC, SDHC, and SDXC. This classification is due to the use of different file systems, and as a result each type has its own frame capacity devices.

A standard SD card SDSC (Standard Capacity), first appeared on the market, could have a maximum size of 2 GB, but they understandably outdated and have virtually not found. Larger cards with a capacity from 2 to 32 GB are of type SDHC (High Capacity), and the most capacious today a card type is SDXC (eXtended Capacity), and their size can reach a theoretical limit of 2 TB.

Each of these types has its own file system. Old SDSC used FAT12 or FAT16, SDHC, moved to the FAT32 file system, and in the most modern SDXC exFAT is used. Here it is worth emphasizing that the use of exFAT caused at the time a lot of disputes. The fact that it is a closed file management system that has limited support in operating systems. As a consequence, SDXC cards may not work in some free Linux distributions, and require a relatively fresh variants of Windows (at least XP SP2 or Vista SP1) and Mac OS X (10.6.5 and above). The same reformatting the SDXC card in a different exFAT file system is possible, but can lead to loss of compatibility with the target gadget, for which it was originally intended.

In 2018 to the list of types SD-card added one – SDUC (Ultra Capacity). It identifies the device with maximum capacity from 2 to 128 TB and continues to use the exFAT file system. In the sale of these cards yet, but obviously soon we will have to deal with the fourth type of SD card.

Although the capacity of SD cards and their type there exists a one-to-one correspondence, to think about the variety of purchased cards you still need. The fact that compatibility between devices and different SD-cards is only one sided. So, if the gadget is compatible with SDXC, it will not only support SDXC but SDHC card. But the device without the support of SDXC cards those cards will not work.

#Speed characteristics of the memory card

Devices of different type using a memory card with different intensity and impose different requirements on their speed characteristics. In order to let users easily choose a memory card in accordance with their needs, the SD Association has introduced additional classification of SD cards for performance levels. In theory it’s supposed to help the correct selection of cards, but with each new version of the standard introduced a new ranking scheme of class performance, and to date, determined for five different parameters that illustrate the speed capabilities of the SD card: speed class, UHS, UHS speed bus, speed class video the class performance for applications.

Manufacturers of memory cards can be used as part or all these options for marking their products, which can cause some confusion. But it’s not as difficult as it seems at first glance.

Speed class (normal). Designation normal speed class (Speed Class) in the form of a number in a circle with a gap you can find almost any memory card or on its packaging. Specification defines four different classes – C2, C4, C6 and C10. This quantitative parameter specifies the minimum guaranteed speed of linear recording in megabytes per second. For example, the class 10 speed means that the recording card will provide a performance not lower than 10 MB/s.

Although sales still continue to meet the memory card of the lower classes of speed, almost all the current offers comply with speed class C10. It is believed that such performance is sufficient for recording at least a standard video stream with a Full HD resolution with standard compression.

Because memory cards of lower speed classes C1, C4 or C6, it is clearly outdated products, the choice we suggest is to immediately dismiss such proposals. Fortunately, the market for them remains very little.

UHS speed class (Ultra High Speed). Here two SD Association defines speed class UHS Speed Class 1 and UHS Speed Class 3. They are indicated by a logo with the letter U, inside which is inscribed the number 1 or 3. UHS class 1 corresponds to the minimum speed of the linear record is 10 MB/s and UHS class 3 guarantees a write speed of 30 MB/s.

While UHS class 1 is actually equivalent to the usual tenth of the speed class, UHS class 3 is a guarantee that the card will record video in Full HD with frame rates up to 120 FPS or standard video to 4K.

Speed bus UHS. Although this speed parameter has a similar name to the previous one, actually no relation to him has. We are not talking about the possibility of the array of flash memory running inside of the card and the bus on which the memory card communicates with the device host. Current memory cards use two versions of the external bus – UHS-I or UHS-II. Version UHS-I allows you to transfer data with a maximum theoretical speed of up to 104 MB/s in one direction, and the UHS-II has a maximum throughput of 312 MB/s in one direction or 156 MB/s in full duplex mode. On memory cards and packages version of the tire is indicated by the usual Roman numeral I or II.

Most memory cards, which are presented in the stores, use the bus UHS-I. gradually, However, begin to meet-and higher-speed UHS-II device. They are easy to distinguish not only marking, but also due to the fact that these memory cards have a second row of contacts, by the use of which achieves the speed increase. However, this also means that although cards that support UHS-II and is able to work with devices with the bus UHS-I, use them in such gadgets makes no sense – the maximum speed they will not develop. However, backward compatibility standards in this case is completely smooth, so if the required speed within the bandwidth of the first version of UHS, it is allowed to install UHS-I card in devices that support UHS-II.

Left – UHS-I microSD card; right – UHS-II microSD card

Also worth mentioning that in 2017 the SD Association released the specification of the bus UHS-III, the capacity of which reaches up to 624 Mbps. At the moment of the existence in nature of memory cards or gadgets with support for UHS-III we do not know, but I’m sure with time the market will come with such solutions.

You need to understand that the bus speed UHS – parameter that has no explicit effect on the performance of the memory card. The implemented version of the tire only determines the maximum speed of the interface. Therefore, purposefully chasing UHS-II devices only makes sense in that case, if you really need a speed of about 90-100 MB/s. While providing such a performance when you record only a single SD card of the last generation, the cost of which exceeds the cost of any UHS-I memory card several times.

Speed rating for video. Another additional feature according to which the SD Association proposes to classify memory cards, a point aimed at an audience of users who shoot videos in high and ultra-high 4K and 8K. Speed class for video (Video Speed Class) is denoted by V and a following number, which is the minimum guaranteed write speed to the card. The specification introduces the following classes: V6, V10, V30, V60 and V90, and to them belong the SD card with the sequential write speed is above 6, 10, 30, 60 or 90 MB/s, respectively.

It is clear that different types of classification have intersection. So, V6 corresponds to the ordinary high-speed class 6; V10 is the same as the speed class 10 or UHS Speed Class 1 and UHS-3 speed intersects with the requirements of the V30. However, such a multiplicity of entities not confused by the SD Association, which presses on the fact that additional classes speed video to allow you to choose a memory card for movies in a more universal single rule. It is believed that while the V30 card should be enough for 4K shooting, the maps corresponding to the classes V60 and V90 should be interested in videographers working with image formats 8K at a frame rate of 60 or even 120 FPS.

If you compare all the classes that characterize the sequential write speed, we get the following table, which should be understood as a cross between speed classes, introduced different editions of the specifications for SD cards.

The minimum speed of the linear record, MB/s Speed class UHS speed class Speed class video
2 C2
4 C4
6 C6 V6
10 C10 U1 V10
30 U3 V30
60 V60
90 V90

Class performance for applications. As soon as memory cards were actively used not only in photo – and videocameras, but also in smartphones or tablets, the SD Association has to think about the necessity of classification from the point of view of their application in such devices. The fact that when using Android devices a critical feature is not only sequential write speed, but the speed of random melkoplodnogo read and write. Operations of this type occur when run from SD-card applications and the storage they work files, and this is a completely different load that has nothing to do with the usual sequential writes.

To rank the cards according to their suitability for installation, storage and running programs was introduced two additional class Application Performance Class A1 and A2. Their logos can also sometimes be detected on SD cards or their packaging.

To quantitatively describe the performance class for applications is not so simple: within these classes are set the minimum speed simultaneously under several loading scenarios.

Class performance for applications Minimum speed of random read IOPS Minimum speed of random writes IOPS The minimum speed of the linear record, MB/s
A1 1500 500 10
A2 4000 2000 10

In addition, the memory card corresponding to the class A2 should maintain a number of additional features more specific to SSD. Among them is the caching of data in the internal DRAM, the job queue of queries and a set of tools for maintenance of the array of flash memory (stand-alone garbage collection).

However, the A2 class was determined just a year ago, and the SD card are not on the market. A pity, because due to the implementation of additional functionality they have become devices to a whole new level, closer in its properties to modern high-tech solid-state media.

#Working voltage

Another characteristic on which different SD card, it is used a signal voltage. Until recently, they used a single voltage level is 3.3 V, but last year, the SD Association introduced LVS-card (Low Voltage Signaling) focused on voltage of 1.8 V and is designed for use in economical devices. Such an energy efficient card should be marked with a special logo with characters LV.

The need to transition to a lower voltage associated with the fact that the high-speed memory card that works with the most rapid options bus UHS-II and UHS-III, began to show excessively high levels of heat dissipation. While for a normal map is characterized by the dispersion of 0.5-1 W of heat at maximum load, the heat dissipation of high performance memory cards can go up to several watts, which causes problems with cooling and it is totally unacceptable for most mobile gadgets.

The standard requires that LVS-card should not become a completely separate class of carriers. Specification requires that they will work with any device that uses as low and usual level of signal voltages. Thus, the problems to the owners of LVS-card – they are suitable everywhere. However, for gadgets that require extremely economical SD cards, suited cards only LVS-varieties.

At the moment the vast majority sold in stores memory card does not support low voltage signal. But gradually they will be more widespread, and their existence must remember when choosing the right mobile carrier information.

#Marking

In theory to understand what the properties of one or the other memory card, can be printed on its obverse surface of the characters. Normal at the moment, the set of markings includes the capacity and type of memory card and class speeds (normal). Often in addition to that you can find the logo version bus UHS and UHS-speed class. Speed class for videos and apps rarely indicated, but such cards also occur. The General principle is: the greater role played by the manufacturer in the SD Association, the more different logos he placed on the map. It is therefore not surprising that especially are full of different markings SanDisk memory card.

However, you need to understand that to focus on the logos – not the wisest decision. First, the conformity of the declared classes is only the opinion of the manufacturer of your product, is not confirmed by any independent tests. Second, the speed classes define mainly only one parameter – speed of the linear record, but in reality memory cards vary and other options performance. Thirdly, the ranking adopted by the SD Association classes allows you to get information about the cards is only a very rough approximation.

All understand this and the producers themselves. So some of them stand in marked or indicated in the specifications is not only classes, but also direct high-speed characteristics of its products. However, most often this is done only in the case when the manufacturer wants to boast speed and then some for additional details on speed in this way can be found only for memory cards with high cost.

#Table tested microSDXC memory card 64 GB

For the first tests (and they certainly will be continued) we have collected common in retail card microSDXC capacity 64 GB. Form factor microSD selected on the basis of the greater prevalence and universality of these cards, because in a standard SD slot they can be mounted via an adapter, which in most cases comes with the microSD card in the kit. The capacity of 64 GB – one of the most popular at the moment offers. Maps of this volume help to save approximately 2880 photo resolution 36 MP, more than two hours of 4K video with high bitrate or more than 6 hours of video with a resolution of Full HD.

Today’s test only affects cards with UHS-I interface — as the most common and most popular options. Higher-speed UHS-II cards have begun to appear on store shelves, but now their acquisition is hardly appropriate: they are expensive and the devices that actually need such high-speed characteristics, are extremely rare.

Most of the testing of the memory cards provided with “M. Video” is one of the leading retail chains selling electronics. This allows us to ensure we reviewed the major memory cards available and popular in Russia.

Before proceeding to a detailed familiarity with the tested microSD cards, it is worth noting one important point. Speed memory cards in each case is determined not only of the inherent speed characteristics, but also by how well implemented the UHS interface in the host. There are cases when the performance of SD cards is not revealed is the fault of the reading device, and to sin in this case, the memory card is clearly not worth it. Big set of examples of situations where performance is constrained by memory card that is on the host side, can be observed with an inexpensive card readers unknown origin that flooded domestic outlets and Chinese online stores.

SOURCE

Advertisement
Click this link to get the Moto Z2 Force for just $31.50/month. Unlimited and device payment activation required. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply.
Code: aPowerES12. Enter this coupon code at checkout to get 12% discount on outlet R630, R730 R730XD and T130 servers. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply.
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Peripherals

The best microSD card with capacity of 128 GB: comparative test 20 models

Advertisement
40807843 Lenovo ThinCentre M90p - Small Form Factor - Intel Core i5-650 3.2Ghz, 4GB RAM, 250GB HDD, Integrated Graphics, Gigabit Ethernet, Windows 10 Professional 64-bit - Refurbished (PC3-0361)

This year, our lab decided to do tests memory cards microSD. These are based on flash memory miniature media information has become ubiquitous and is actively used not only in all sorts of gadgets to capture photos and video, but in the portable devices based on the Android operating system in smartphones and tablets. Consequently, their proper choice arose great interest that we have in process of forces and possibilities to meet.

The first article in the series was devoted to the comparison of microSD cards with capacity of 64 GB. To start with this volume we decided, based on its popularity, sales statistics says that, although the most popular goods are rather cheap memory cards 16 and 32 GB, the interest in the 64-Gigabyte cards are also considerable. But most importantly, the customers, the 64-Gigabyte cards treat them much more picky. A significant influence on the choice starts to have is not so much the price of the device, as its performance characteristics, reliability, warranty and brand reputation.

In the comments to our first material many readers requested to conduct similar tests and memory cards microSD larger volume of 128 or even 256 GB. We decided to ignore the request and move along axis of the container on. Of course, memory cards with capacity of 128 GB cannot be considered as popular choices as the 64-Gigabyte microSD cards: they are more expensive, and because they buy about half as often. However, if you look at the sales statistics for last year interest to a roomy microSD cards has increased almost four times. And that means that a 128-Gigabyte storage media for portable devices could from decisions of interest to only a especially demanding consumers, to turn into a quite popular product.

That is why the second article of the cycle affects memory cards with capacity of 128 GB. And immediately it should be clear that these cards are very different from the 64-Gigabyte, and their individual testing makes sense. Important features there are two. First, the composition of the products, available in capacity of 128 Gbytes, is different from the range 64-Gigabyte cards. Spacious microSD card is more difficult to manufacture, so offer them only to those manufacturers that have advanced technology and have the opportunity to purchase the latest types of flash memory. Second, the speed parameters of memory cards vary according to their capacity. More capacious options of microSD cards are built on more stacked cards inside the crystals NAND, which gives the opportunity to implement various techniques of alternating access, which increases the efficiency of the array of flash memory. As a result, the higher card volume are usually faster, but the relationship is not direct, because so much depends on the Manager, the flash memory controller.

#MicroSD memory cards: what you need to know

Nonetheless to reminisce about the past testing of memory cards today we will have repeatedly. After all that time we have not only identified the most attractive proposals among the 64 GB microSD card (then won Samsung EVO Plus), but also learned a lot about the current state of the market as a whole. The understanding of previously obtained results allows to approach more systematically and to better understand which features microSD are more critical and which signs you should pay the most attention.

First and foremost, we learned that almost all modern microSD card, running on the bus UHS-I read speed rests in the bandwidth of the interface. The situation here is the same as with a SATA SSD when any such drive will provide the same speed of linear reading. The only difference is that the bus UHS-I has a theoretical bandwidth of 104 Mbytes/s, this sets the maximum read speed with UHS-I microSD cards. In practice, almost any card will issue a sequential read speed of at 95-100 MB/s. Deviation is only possible for two reasons: either the device that uses the map has its own speed limit, or talking about some old or just a bad sample. For example, in the past testing the 64-Gigabyte microSD card low speed when reading was detected only in Kingston Canvas Select, from the cheapest of the cards SONY Russian-made and outdated models of Transcend cards.

Exceeding 100 MB/s speed performance for linear reading is possible only with the next version of the interface — UHS-II. Cards that use this already available for sale, but we do reserve outside the focus of attention for two reasons. First, they are quite rare and much more expensive UHS-I cards. Second, the gadgets, which support UHS-II cards are not so widely that ultimately makes the UHS-II cards niche or even a niche offer.

A second General conclusion concerns the fact that the main characteristic on which microSD card do differ is the speed of the linear record. Actually, it in most cases depends on whether the card to save the video stream at a particular resolution, or how it will manifest itself in serial photography. And at first glance here it seems all very clear, after all, the standardization organization of the SD Association, has developed a simple system of marking classes which describe the building of a map.

The standard stipulates three characteristics, the ranking speed of the linear record: speed class, UHS speed class and speed class for the video. They were introduced into circulation successively, and therefore set their minimum speed intersect. However, if the manufacturer indicates in the description of the card, what class speed it relates to choose the appropriate option seems to be a very simple task.

The minimum speed of the linear record, MB/s Speed class UHS speed class Speed class video
2 C2
4 C4
6 C6 V6
10 C10 U1 V10
30 U3 V30
60 V60
90 V90

But there it was. As shown, the correct description of high-speed classes are almost never found. But it’s not that manufacturers are overly optimistic about the capabilities of their products, quite the contrary. Speed classes are declared in most cases is conservative, promising more low, than is actually performance. Moreover, many manufacturers confine myself to an indication of the speed class and the UHS speed class, and the parameter “speed class” video in General is lowered. More or less follows the established ranking system only SanDisk, while the bulk micro SD products from other manufacturers explicitly promises only belong to classes C10 and U3, which means a guaranteed write speed at 30 MB/s. In reality, the recording speed can exceed this value and twice, and three times, but to learn about it on formal grounds in advance is not always possible.

Sometimes more specific indicators of performance memory cards when recording can be found on the websites of their manufacturers. But the practice detailed description microSD cards, which are perceived by many as a simple accessory for consumer electronics, not as a high-tech device based on flash memory, cannot be called universal. In other words, without thinking to find out which memory cards will work faster when recording data, not so easy. This task can hardly be solved, while in the store, and the answer to the question “What to choose?” can only give tests like those conducted on our website.

An even more serious problem arises if you need to know not the linear speed, and performance maps for arbitrary reading and writing. These characteristics are critical in the case when the card is used in Android-device for storing programs and user files, but usually they are not addressed at all. Generally speaking, in the specification, the SD Association provides the class definitions of the speed for applications A1 and A2 for the performance under arbitrary operations, but in fact I use them even less frequently than classes of speed for video.

Class performance for applications Minimum speed of random read IOPS Minimum speed of random writes IOPS The minimum speed of the linear record, MB/s
A1 1500 500 10
A2 4000 2000 10

When we tested the 64-Gigabyte microSD card, class A1 was specified for only three of the seventeen cards, but tests showed that in fact, under its requirements fit more than half of the tested cards. Thus, the performance in random read – option carries even more uncertainty. And adopted the industry classification system speeds while the issue of choice is absolutely not facilitated.

Past testing of memory cards allowed to find out one more interesting detail. It turns out that the memory card based on MLC NAND, is still present in the market. However, they take approximately the same position as the SSD of two-bit memory. Keep them in your range only a few manufacturers (especially Samsung and Transcend), while most of the market options – the microSD card on the basis of TLC 3D NAND. Such exclusivity of products with two-bit memory, allowing you to position them as specialized high-reliability solutions, e.g. for video recorders, time continuous use which can total several years. Resource entries when it is artificially restricted by lowering the speed, so often as the microSD card having the name or description of the phrase High Endurance (“high reliability”), are typically slower than standard cards with TLC-memory inside, despite the higher price.

Now that we briefly know what generalized conclusions we came to when testing memory cards microSD 64 GB, it’s time to move on to a memory card twice the volume, test, that you kindly asked after the last of the material.

#Table tested microSDXC memory card 128GB

Thus, this test includes microSDXC card with UHS-I interface and a capacity of 128 GB.

Recall that these memory cards are the most versatile. They are suitable for compact devices that have slots for microSD installation initially, but can be placed in devices that support regular SD cards. There are special adapters that manufacturers microSD cards are often included in the package. It should be emphasized that all such adapter is a passive component that does not have any logic inside. They provide only mechanical compatibility and therefore do not affect performance, and there is no reason to avoid using them are there.

Participants test their stated manufacturers specifications listed in the following table.

For this test we’ve tried to gather all the relevant options microSDXC card with UHS-I interface and a capacity of 128 GB available. And as you can see, we almost succeeded. Not included in testing only memory cards are small producers of the third echelon, whose sales are insignificant on the General background. In other words, we checked all major memory cards available and popular in Russia, and they were many – two dozen.

SOURCE

Advertisement
Code: VZWDEAL. Enter this coupon code at checkout to get $100 discount on Samsung Galaxy Note 8. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply. Device payment purchase required.
Samsung J7 V just $5 mo. New device payment purchase req'd. Plus, free shipping.
Continue Reading

Peripherals

Review of an external SSD drive, Samsung Portable SSD T5: pocket 850 EVO

Advertisement
Code: VZWDEAL. Enter this coupon code at checkout to get $100 discount on Samsung Galaxy Note 8. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply. Device payment purchase required.

Range of products of Samsung, is based on the flash memory is not limited to the internal SSD. Yes, SATA and NVMe SSD is one of the most popular and popular products for Samsung users of computer technology, but its proprietary 3D V-NAND memory, the South Korean manufacturer applies for the production of and other categories products: memory cards and external portable SSD. And these products is not related suggestions made on the principle of “to be”, and it is high quality and interesting characteristics of the products in their respective categories to fight for the leadership.

The right to say so came out of nowhere. Recently we tested the microSD card and came to the conclusion that Samsung EVO Plus is one of the best media for photo/video equipment and mobile devices. Today we talk about the Samsung Portable SSD T5 – external portable data carrier, which according to formal characteristics, also seems to be the leader among all similar solutions. At least if we talk about those drives which have a USB interface.

Besides, T5 is not a pen test, and the result of the evolutionary development of the respective hardware platform. South Korean developers involved in the design and construction of portable SSD since the beginning of 2015, when the world saw the first Samsung external drive – T1. T5, in turn, is already the third edition of the Samsung pocket drive with USB interface. It appeared about a year ago, but to this day remains a very relevant proposal. Looming just on the horizon new external SSD called the Samsung X5 is not a mass and does not replace the T5 product for the reason that it relies on rare Thunderbolt interface. Samsung T5, unlike the X5, you can use everywhere – not just any computers, but even with tablets and smartphones based on Android operating system.

#Specifications

In General, the SSD – not too popular decisions. As the proliferation of various cloud services, the need for such devices declined markedly. However, high-speed Internet at your fingertips is not always the case, and in this case Samsung T5 able to help. The basic idea, which is embedded in the hardware design of this drive is quite simple: the external SSD have to offer about the same features that ensure the internal SSD. T5 was created with an eye to users when communicating with them had about the same experience as working with a normal SATA SSD.

This is achieved in a fairly simple way: the Samsung Portable SSD T5 is a variation popular in the last internal drive 850 EVO, adapted to work via the USB interface. It is therefore not surprising that the hardware of the external model consists of a 64-layer flash memory 3D TLC V-NAND the fourth generation (this memory was used in 850 EVO is the third version and is used in 860 Samsung EVO) which is controlled by a standard controller Samsung MGX. However, as external link Samsung T5 is not used SATA, and USB 3.1 Gen 2 with theoretical bandwidth up to 10 Gbps, which allows the T5 to offer roughly the same performance characteristics as the 850/860 EVO.

Samsung Portable SSD T5
Capacity 250 GB, 500 GB, 1 TB, 2 TB
Interface USB 3.1 Gen 2 (10 Gbps) backwards compatible
Data transfer rate Up to 540 MB/s
Size 74 × 57,3 × 10.5 mm
Weight 51 g
Mode UASP (USB Attached SCSI Protocol) Supported
Encryption Hardware AES-c 256-bit key
Guarantee Three years
Price (official) 250 GB — 7 490 rubles.
500 GB — 9 990 RUB.
1 TB — 19 990 rubles.
2 TB — 39 990 rubles.

Lineup Samsung T5 includes four SSDS with capacities from 250 GB to 2 TB and overall characteristics of the corresponding models coincide with those specifications that were declared for the Samsung 850 EVO: in particular, the maximum speed of sequential access is limited to the value of 540 MB/s. Yes, it is not up to the bandwidth of USB 3.1 Gen 2, but T5 will still obviously more productive than those outside the SSD, which are based on the last version of USB 3.1 Gen 1 – there is a maximum data transfer rate is limited by the value of 450 MB/s.

Based on the bandwidth of USB 3.1 Gen 2, Samsung T5 could be faster, but the problem is that it is based on MGX controller, originally designed to work with SATA. T5 is implemented is not the most elegant solution to sum up this drive, with USB 3.1 Gen 2, it added the additional host bridge SATA-USB. This approach increases delay and does not fully use the entire bandwidth of the latest version of the USB interface, but it allows Samsung to unify the SATA and USB drives and reduce the cost of T5.

In addition to the use of additional front-end of the bridge, the Samsung Portable SSD T5 is different from internal drives and another fundamental point – the type of the default file system. Initially, the external drive is formatted with exFAT and not under the usual for Windows users NTFS. This is done with a specific intent: NTFS is a closed file system that does not have full support in operating systems Linux (e.g. in MacOS or Android), so to extend the T5 compatibility with different devices, developers have relied on a more common alternative. The result is your Samsung external drive without any problems can be used not only with computers but also with mobile devices, game consoles, media centers, smart TVs and so on. However, nothing prevents the user in case of need to reformat to NTFS and T5.

The rest of Samsung T5 quite predictable. What we saw in the Samsung 850 EVO, one way or another is available in the drive. For example, in the T5 uses a standard SSD technology is Samsung SLC TurboWrite cache as well as SATA SSD to visually see her work only in version external SSD with a capacity of 250 GB. More capacious versions of the T5 have a sufficient degree of parallelism of the array of flash memory that allows you to demonstrate writing speed 500 MB/sec for the entire capacity of the SSD.

Unlike many other external drives, Samsung T5 under the Protocol UASP (USB attached SCSI) supports the TRIM command, which allows him to demonstrate consistently high recording speed, is not subject to any degradation as you use.

However, it requires support from the operating system. For example, if we talk about Windows, the flow TRIM it to exFAT file system is not possible. So if you are going to use the T5 primarily with Windows computers, reformat it to the NTFS file system is not devoid of meaning.

However, even in the case of a standard T5 for exFAT file system, typical for external drives linear operations performance degradation due to the exhaustion of the pool of free pages on flash memory is not observed. The firmware this drive has been optimised to maintain the constancy of the speed of sequential writes, and she is very good at it. No drops write performance on Samsung T5 large files is not observed, at least if we are talking about storage capacity of 500 GB and above, where the array of flash memory has a sufficient degree of parallelism.

Like their desktop counterparts, Samsung T5 supports encryption with AES-256. To activate a hardware cryptographic engine to the program (in versions for Windows, Mac OS and Android), which is encrypted SSD hidden in a special read-only partition of the drive capacity of 81 MB.

Encryption uses the hardware features of the controller Samsung MGX, and its inclusion does not lead to any performance degradation.

Have with Samsung T5 and quite detailed S. M. A. R. T. diagnostics, which has a complete set of characteristic drives the South Korean manufacturer settings. In particular, available data about the development of the resource and the condition of the cells of the flash memory. However, keep in mind that compatibility with T5 have not all the programs for monitoring the disk subsystem, but only those who understand the Protocol UASP.

#Appearance and internal structure

Design the Samsung Portable SSD T5 corresponds to its purpose. The drive has a fairly small size (slightly more than half of the usual 2.5-inch SATA SSD – 74 × 57,3 × 10.5 mm) and light weight (about 50 grams). Made of the considered SSD in a flat metal case with rounded edges, allowing you to carry it in your pocket and not damage clothes. In addition, the body made of metal, makes the T5 solution is very reliable in mechanical terms is to break it during transport or use almost impossible. And the ability of the drive to endure the fall with two-meter height made in the specification. However, moisture not declared.

To connect the drive on one of its ends is located the slot of the USB Type-C. the Necessary connecting cables are included in the package. Samsung has not stinted on two USB cable: cable with two plugs Type-C on both ends and the cable, one end of which ends with plug Type A. this means that the T5 comes with everything needed for its interface as with desktop computers, and mobile devices. However, it should be noted that the wiring length is only 45 cm.

Next to the USB connector on the end of the drive is disguised as a blue led, illustrating the performance and activity of the gadget.

Case T5 has two color variations depending on the volume SSD. Blue colors are provided for versions with a capacity of 250 and 500 GB, black same color is used for the terabyte and dvuhterabaytny model.

For detailed acquaintance with the device Samsung T5 us was dismantled modification capacity of 500 GB. And no wonder – the inside of this external SSD proved to be very interesting. The fact that he was assembled from two separate parts: the adapter from the USB 3.1 Gen 2 mSATA and a full drive in the mSATA version.

The adapter is made on the basis of single-chip bridge ASMedia ASM235CM: on the one hand it carries USB 3.1 Gen 2 Type-C, and on the other is equipped with a mSATA slot that you are installing to a SATA drive a corresponding form factor. An important feature of this adapter – redundant power scheme in which there are three capacitor of 100 microfarads, is needed to prevent data loss when sudden power outages T5 from a computer or external device.

As for the set in the adapter mSATA drive, that’s a regular Samsung 850 EVO third version in the mSATA version. In this case, the drive capacity is 500 GB, it really is based on a 64-layer TLC 3D V-NAND recruited two chips K9OMGY8H5A equipped with Samsung MGX controller and LPDDR3 memory-buffer in size of 512 MB.

Special about this Samsung 850 EVO just firmware. She has an obvious optimization for the sequential operations and adapted to the exFAT file system.

It is worth noting that e-filling Samsung T5 does not use aluminum casing for its cooling: no termoenergetyczny pads, allowing the heat away from the chip controller and flash memory in the design is not provided. And it is in vain: when recording on an external SSD large amounts of data it can overheat. Upon reaching the temperature of the drive 65-degree mark turns on the throttle, resulting in a temporary drop in performance of the drive by about half.

SOURCE

Advertisement
Samsung J7 V just $5 mo. New device payment purchase req'd. Plus, free shipping.
Save $50 and receive free two-day shipping on Focal Sib Evo 5.1 Home Cinema System!
Continue Reading

Peripherals

Overview NVMe drives Toshiba: XG5-P, XG5 and BG3

Advertisement
Code: VZWDEAL. Enter this coupon code at checkout to get $100 discount on Samsung Galaxy Note 8. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply. Device payment purchase required.

Speaking of storage, the Toshiba company can be safely attributed to the number of leading players at least because it has not only a flash memory but with the development Department engaged in the creation of controllers and original designs SSD. Such vertical integration to date, has mastered only a few. But in addition, Toshiba was able to win a significant enough market share, which in the last quarter unexpectedly exceeded 10 percent and that Toshiba came in third place for the supply of the SSD after Samsung and Western Digital. I must say that for the layman such statistics sounds surprising, since the Toshiba drives come in-assembled computers very rarely, and just not common in retail. However, the fact remains: the power Tohisba is the ability to work with OEM manufacturers, and ready-made computers and laptops from manufacturers such as, for example, Dell or MSI solid state drives this company really are very frequent.

However, from time to time Toshiba has attempted to expand its presence in the retail market. So, with this purpose, it in 2013 was bought by American brand OCZ, under which the company began to sell their featured products. In parallel but separate model drives Toshiba is trying to promote under its own brand, and, interestingly, a one-to-one correspondence between sentences of OCZ and Toshiba is not. Moreover, with the popularity of the NVMe interface as a means of connecting SSD drives, Toshiba began to use their traditional Japanese brand. As a result, the current lineup NVMe drives Toshiba really deserves a detailed acquaintance: on the one hand, it includes interesting consumer characteristics of the products, on the other, albeit limited, but its representatives still meet on the shelves of local stores.

Today we will get acquainted with up to three NVMe SSD Toshiba: XG5-P, XG5 and BG3. All of them have in common is that they are based on a proprietary 64-layer TLC 3D NAND, which the company produces under the marketing name BiCS3 (Bit Cost Scalable). We have already met several times with drives from other vendors, built on the basis of a memory, and experience suggests that three-dimensional memory Toshiba has everything you need to be a good Foundation for a SSD with a good combination of performance and price. Particularly revealing example in this regard recently tested in our laboratory WD Black NVMe. This drive showed that BiCS3 memory at least is not inferior in performance to the 64-layer flash memory competitors, and with the right approach and optimization algorithms it can be an excellent basis for high-performance solutions.

However, confuses one “but”. We all remember that of all the options the 64-layer TLC 3D NAND memory Toshiba is demonstrating in tests not too optimistic endurance. However, private drives, the Japanese manufacturer is and may well not deal with: there is a high likelihood that products sold under its own name, chooses the best Toshiba semiconductor crystals, selling at way less good silicon.

As a result, today’s testing can be a source of new revelation: we will look at actual fast NVMe drives Toshiba, which claim to compete with the recognized leaders. At least, this is evidenced by their price: are SSD, Toshiba’s expensive and how it is justified, we will see below.

#Toshiba XG5

XG5 at the moment is the base NVMe-range Toshiba. Now the company has a more advanced model XG6, which uses freshly-96-layer memory BiCS4, but until the supply of these novelties are only a trial, since the production of three-dimensional memory of the fourth generation are running the Toshiba only in pilot mode.

As for Toshiba XG5 is fully debugged and streamlined design, which uses components produced commercially and in large quantities. The display is its own controller Toshiba TC58NCP090GSD developed by the engineers of the Japanese company. Little is known about him, but, judging from the markings, it can be assumed that this controller is a further development of the chip TC58NCP070GSB used in the OCZ RD400. This may mean that some support for the development of a new platform was provided by company Marvell, but no official confirmation of this.

An array of flash memory in Toshiba XG5 assembled at the eight-channel scheme, it is made up of the TLC 3D NAND devices of the third generation ( Toshiba BiCS3). Architecture BiCS3 defines two sizes of crystals – 256 and 512 GB, and both variations of this are used to XG5. Memory with less cores is placed in version storage volume of 256 and 512 GB, and memory cores a capacity of 512 GB gets into the terabyte modifications. Therefore, Toshiba is working to increase the level of parallelism of the array of flash memory, and even the younger version XG5 can offer quite high performance.

Toshiba XG5 specification is as follows:

Manufacturer Toshiba
Series XG5
Model number KXG5AZNV256G KXG5AZNV512G KXG5AZNV1T02
Form factor M. 2 2280
Interface PCI Express 3.0 x4 NVMe 1.2
Capacity, GB 256 512 1024
Configuration
Memory chips: type, interface, process technology, manufacturer Toshiba 64-layer 256-Gbit 3D-NAND TLC (BiCS3) Toshiba 64-layer 512 GB TLC 3D NAND (BiCS3)
Controller Toshiba TC58NCP090GSD
Buffer: type, volume DDR3L-1866, 256 MB DDR3L-1866, 256 MB DDR3L-1866, 512 MB
Performance
Max. sustained sequential read, MB/s 2700 3000 3000
Max. sustained sequential write speed, MB/s 1050 1050 2100
Max. speed of random read (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a N/a N/a
Max. speed random write (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a N/a N/a
Physical characteristics
Power consumption: inaction/read-write, W 0,003/4,5
MTBF (mean time between failures), million h 1,5
Resource record, TB N/a N/a N/a
Dimensions: Ghvhg, mm 80 x 22 x 2,23
Weight, g 7,3
Warranty period, years N/a

Curiously, Toshiba has decided not to specify for XG5 indicators performance melloblocco load. Usually this comes for UN-buffered SSD designs to ahead of time not to shock the potential buyers, but XG5 tactic of “partial silence” is rather linked to something else. DRAM buffer in the drive is provided, however, it has several lower-than-usual volume, and per Gigabyte of storage capacity has 512 KB of RAM.

Another interesting detail of the specifications of the duality of performance: in addition to the base level Toshiba leads the other slightly lower. The fact that XG5 is available with two versions of the firmware and the manufacturers of laptops, for which it is important an operating time from batteries, can request for a slower version with reduced energy appetites.

As in any other consumer drive on the basis of a three-bit memory cells, high speed when you record data provided by the SLC algorithms-caching. The XG5 cache implemented on a static scheme, and its size is very small. For example, in version SSD 1 TB cache size was about 3 GB. And this means that when writing significant amounts of data, the SSD will have to face a drop in performance. This is clearly seen on the graph showing the speed of continuous linear recording XG5 capacity of 1 terabyte large file.

The memory array assembled from 16 devices BiCS3 (as in the XG5 512GB or 1TB), can provide pretty good speed and in live recordings in TLC mode – about 900 MB/s. But it is below the speed of direct memory writes from the best models of competing NVMe SSD, such as NVMe WD Black or the Samsung 970 EVO.

Externally, the Toshiba drive XG5 looks quite unassuming. No heat sinks, and heat-dissipating labels in standard not provided. Moreover, it shows that it is an OEM product: on the label on the drive, given only the article, and nowhere marketing the product name.

Special mention deserves the fact that all the chips on the XG5 is located on one side of the M. 2 card form factor 2280. This design is useful for use in thin laptops, where the often used “low” slots. To achieve the same compactness engineers Toshiba have due to the placement of all the semiconductor crystals BiCS3 that make up the array of flash memory, only two chips. For example, in tested in our laboratory version of the SSD capacity of 1 terabyte each chip flash memory contained inside 8 crystals.

 

According to the requirements of corporate customers, XG5 and supports encryption. The label is the PSID is the key. But implemented in the firmware of the cryptographic engine is responsible only to the TCG OPAL standard, that is, work with Windows BitLocker is not supported.

#Toshiba XG5-P

XG5-P is the advanced version of the previous drive, which Toshiba introduced a little later, the original version. At the announcement of this model was said about improved speeds melkoplodnyj operations and the expansion of the model range upwards to limits. So, with the release XG5-P was the available storage capacity of 2 TB, though in this case the updated a series not included the Junior version.

In the end, the specifications XG5-P got the following.

Manufacturer Toshiba
Series XG5-P
Model number KXG5APNV1T02 KXG5APNV2T04
Form factor M. 2 2280
Interface PCI Express 3.0 x4 NVMe 1.2
Capacity, GB 1024 2048
Configuration
Memory chips: type, interface, process technology, manufacturer Toshiba 64-layer 256-Gbit 3D-NAND TLC (BiCS3) Toshiba 64-layer 512 GB TLC 3D NAND (BiCS3)
Controller Toshiba TC58NCP090GSD
Buffer: type, volume LPDDR3-1866, 1 GB LPDDR3-1866, 2GB
Performance
Max. sustained sequential read, MB/s 3000 3000
Max. sustained sequential write speed, MB/s 2100 2200
Max. speed of random read (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a 320 000
Max. speed random write (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a 265 000
Physical characteristics
Power consumption: inaction/read-write, W 0,003/4,9
MTBF (mean time between failures), million h 1,5
Resource record, TB N/a N/a
Dimensions: Ghvhg, mm 80 x 22 x 2,23
Weight, g 7,3
Warranty period, years N/a

Here are Toshiba already did not hesitate to report the performance for random reads and writes, but the high will not name them: they are about one and a half times less than promises 970 Samsung EVO WD Black or NVMe. As for the speed of linear operations, compared to XG5 they have not changed.

Improved performance in XG5-P passed with relatively little rework on the hardware level. It does not change either the base controller or PCB design. The growth performance is due to three fairly simple steps. First, the introduction of microprogram optimization. Secondly, increasing the degree of parallelism of the array of flash memory. And third, by increasing the capacity of DRAM buffer.

If older versions XG5 in the chip was Packed in 8 units BiCS3, XG5-P they are already 16. Due to this the drive controller got the opportunity to use more effective fourfold alternating devices in their channels. In addition, the DRAM buffer is increased in volume by half and purchased a standard size calculated according to the formula “1 MB to 1 GB”.

In this case the engineers decided not to touch the algorithms SLC-caching, which in the previous version caused some criticism due to the small amount of cache. But even on a 2-terabyte version XG5-P high speed can be recorded just the same 3 GB of data. Here’s how it looks on the chart performance of linear continuous recording:

Speed direct sequential write to the flash memory XG5-P increased compared to XG5 about 10 percent, but this can hardly be considered a major achievement.

Externally, XG5-P is almost indistinguishable from the XG5. Gives a new modification only using DDR3 chips made by Samsung, and not the Nanya. But this is a minor change.

Most importantly, even 2-terabyte version XG5-P has retained one-sided design. So, releasing a SSD drive, Toshiba met the inquiries of the manufacturers of slim laptops who want to install in your system SSD the high capacity. Moreover, according to the specifications, XG5-P was neither more greedy nor more than hot.

 

#Toshiba BG3

BG3 is a very special and unique in many ways NVMe-product of Toshiba. Initially it is a single chip drive BGA (Ball Grid Array), focused on the OEM market. The idea behind SSD is that the controller and the crystals NAND placed in a single BGA package size of 16×20 mm can be mounted directly on the printed circuit Board in miniature devices is usually applied in such cases eMMC devices. However, in addition to the BGA-version, Toshiba has decided to offer a “custom” option BG3, is made in the standard M. 2 module, but with very small sizes to suit the form factor 2230 (22×30 mm).

Generally speaking, form factor M. 2 2230 is supported in hardware are rare. Therefore, Toshiba BG3 is a specific product. Have BG3 is more convenient to use in mass systems version with size 2242, it is sold under the name Toshiba RC100. However, for this review we received from the manufacturer is BG3, and therefore see firsthand: drives M. 2 2230 support not every motherboard.

Toshiba develops range of drives in the BGA-version with 2015. BG3 is the most relevant SSD of this kind, which, as described above and XG5 XG5-P uses in its design, the flash memory Toshiba BiCS3 – TLC 3D NAND the third generation with 64 vertically spaced layers. For such drives the developers of Toshiba use some special controllers, about the device which do not have any details. However, apparently it is quite intelligent in its solution properties.

Although a single chip design and SSDS seem to be quite an interesting discovery, you need to understand that such miniaturization is not cost free. Such drives have limited capacity, and in addition, they can use a wide front end tires. So, Toshiba BG3 is connected to the system with only two lines PCI Express 3.0. The maximum volume of such a device is 512 GB. Another limitation is the lack of the design of the drive DRAM buffer. So BG3 is a compromise between size and performance. But a clear advantage is achieved in heat dissipation and power consumption. The same BG3 somewhere in half to two times more economical than any other NVMe SSD.

We should not think that the Toshiba BG3 is very bad for performance the drive. Its specifications given below, and it is clear that it will quickly some full-fledged desktop solutions, for example, the same Kingston A1000.

Manufacturer Toshiba
Series BG3
Model number KBG3AZMS128G KBG3AZMS256G KBG3AZMS512G
Form factor M. 2 2280
Interface PCI Express 3.0 x2 – NVMe 1.2
Capacity, GB 128 256 512
Configuration
Memory chips: type, interface, process technology, manufacturer Toshiba 64-layer 512 GB TLC 3D NAND (BiCS3)
Controller Toshiba
Buffer: type, volume No
Performance
Max. sustained sequential read, MB/s 1300 1400 1500
Max. sustained sequential write speed, MB/s 600 800 1000
Max. speed of random read (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a N/a N/a
Max. speed random write (blocks 4 KB) IOPS N/a N/a N/a
Physical characteristics
Power consumption: inaction/read-write, W 0,005/3.3 V
MTBF (mean time between failures), million h 1,5
Resource record, TB N/a N/a N/a
Dimensions: Ghvhg, mm 30 x 22 x 2,38
Weight, g 2,6
Warranty period, years N/a

The secret ingredient unbuffered Toshiba BG3 lies in support for NVMe Host Memory Buffer (HMB), which is discussed in detail in the review of the Transcend SSD 110S. The bottom line is that in the compatible operating systems (for example, in current builds of Windows 10) BG3 can use for their needs the main memory when it is accessed directly via the PCI Express bus in the DMA mode. This allows the drive does not lose performance when melkoplodnyj operations, as occurs with other SSD models dispossession of DRAM. In addition, regarding the consumption of main system memory, do not worry: the drive is reserved for their needs just about 10 MB.

Helps to raise productivity and technology SLC-cache. In BG3, as in other Toshiba drives, it is implemented in a static scheme, but the amount of cache is increased: record in accelerated mode possible for very large amounts of information. So, when sequentially writing data to a free BG3 with a capacity of 512 GB, you can observe the following picture of performance.

The entry in SLC-mode is performed at a speed of around 900 Mbps and on a clean drive at a pace you can record approximately 16 GB of information. In TLC mode the speed of the linear record falls to more typical SATA SSD 400 MB/s, but in fairness it should be noted that normal users hardly face.

It turns out that although on-chip performance, BG3 is a normal budget NVMe drive using to connect the bus PCI Express 3.0 x2. Its main feature – not an unusual performance, and appearance. And look at it definitely is: the much smaller size of the SSD in our lab has not happened.

 

Do: on a printed circuit Board mounted just one chip that fit all. In addition to the controller chip shown in the photos of the drive capacity of 512 GB is eight crystals BiCS3 memory with capacity of 512 GB. However, in fairness it should be noted that it BG3 is still present some additional electronic components that implement the power plan. But still, the size of the drive is comparable with the size of the SD card, and it’s impressive. Such a tiny SSD is certainly suitable not only for compact mobile computers, but also, for example, for IoT devices.

SOURCE

Advertisement
Liquid Web Black Friday/ Cyber Week Managed Dedicated Server Special. Save 50% for 3 Months on upgraded Dedicated Server products! Starting at $149/mo!
Liquid Web Dedicated Servers: Starting at $796/mo. Now! Limited time only! Fast SSD Drives! Fully Managed! Best in Class Support!
Continue Reading

Deals

Advertisement
Samsung J7 V just $5 mo. New device payment purchase req'd. Plus, free shipping.
Code: VZWDEAL. Enter this coupon code at checkout to get $100 discount on Samsung Galaxy Note 8. Includes free shipping. Restrictions may apply. Device payment purchase required.
Go through this link and get up to $500 discount on weekly deals. Free shipping included. Restrictions may apply.

Trending